To call M J Rosenberg ‘a fiercely anti-Israel writer’ is really bizarre use of language, even for the JPost. M J’s greatest sin was to tell the interested public that WINEP was an AIPAC front. Previous posts about the synthetic ‘Israel-Firster’ furore, in reverse chronological order, here, here, and here – RB
Group slams Jewish funding of ‘anti-Jewish’ NGOs
Benjamin Weinthal, JPost, Mar 4 2012
The US-based group Emergency Committee for Israel published a full-page advertisement in the NYT last week urging readers and sponsors to question why Jewish philanthropies are supporting Media Matters and the Center for American Progress, two anti-Israel organizations accused of spreading anti-Semitic rhetoric. The ad on Thursday asked:
The Center for American Progress and Media Matters claim to be in the liberal mainstream. But is being anti-Israel a liberal value?
The ad includes a cartoon of a wolf holding a sheep mask, suggesting that Jewish philanthropy groups are being hoodwinked by the two organizations’ anti-Israel agendas. Media Matters is a left-wing media watchdog organization. CAP is a think tank associated with the US Democratic Party and Obama’s Middle East policies. The Washington-based Emergency Committee’s ad includes a breakdown of Jewish organizations that donate to the two organizations. According to the roster, the Combined Jewish Philanthropies of Greater Boston, the Community Foundation of the United Jewish Federation of San Diego and the Jewish Communal Fund donate to both. Foundations with a non-Jewish focus were also listed in the ad. The Emergency Committee ad cites recent quotations from the AJC, ADL and Simon Wiesenthal Center attacking CAP’s anti-Israel and anti-Jewish agenda. CAP garnered widespread media attention in the US when a faction of bloggers took to the organization’s ThinkProgress website and Twitter, and charged that supporters of Israel were agents of the Jewish state engaged in treason against the US. Two of these bloggers, Zaid Jilani and Ali Gharib, used variations of the white supremacist term “Israel-Firster” to smear a US senator and advocates for the security of the Jewish state. According to information obtained by the JPost, CAP discharged Jilani but continues to retain a group of writers who have over the years downplayed the Iranian nuclear weapons program and contributed to the delegitimization of Israel’s right to exist. CAP spokeswoman Andrea Purse refused to comment when asked about the ad. She did email the JPost in late February regarding the organization’s policy on staff anti-Semitism:
The Center for American Progress is and always has been pro-Israel, committed to a peace process that produces a durable two state solution negotiated by the parties, and it takes seriously the threat posed by Iran and its nuclear activities. We have a zero tolerance policy on anti-Semitism. We have written critically about its continuing use in contemporary political debates, and we take any allegation of anti-Semitism extremely seriously. A very small number of tweets on the personal accounts of ThinkProgress staff were inappropriate, and the authors have publicly apologized for using objectionable language.
According to experts, anti-Semitic and anti-Israel rhetoric continue to appear on CAP’s blogs, an allegation Purse denied. She said:
That language never appeared in any CAP or ThinkProgress publication, and we have taken steps to ensure that all CAP staff maintain the highest standards in their communications, even in their personal social media accounts.
Unlike CAP, Media Matters has not touted a zero tolerance policy against such language. Additionally, M J Rosenberg, a fiercely anti-Israel writer, continues to work for Media Matters and has defended the use of the phrase “Israel-Firster” to denigrate supporters of Israel. Thursday’s ad cites quotes from liberal US Jews blasting the two organizations for stoking anti-Semitism. According to Alan Dershowitz:
Media Matters and Center for American Progress are two extremely left, bigoted groups that are so virulently anti-Israel and anti-supporters of Israel that they’ve gone over the line from anti-Zionism to anti-Semitism. When I started reading their stuff, it sounded like the kind of stuff you read on neo-Nazi websites, or on Hezbollah-supporter websites, it is so extremist.
The ad also quoted from an article in the online magazine Tablet by Spencer Ackerman:
For months, M J Rosenberg of Media Matters, the progressive media watchdog group, has been throwing around the term ‘Israel-Firster’ to describe conservatives he disagrees with. ‘Israel-Firster’ has a nasty anti-Semitic pedigree.
When asked about whether Media Matters supports the use of the term and Rosenberg’s writings, Media Matters spokeswoman Jess Levin told theJ Post that she would be in touch. However, a follow-up JPost email to Levin was not immediately returned. Speaking from Washington, former AIPAC spokseman Josh Block told the JPost on the phone:
Unlike CAP, which has condemned what they called ‘terrible anti-Semitic language’ used by their staff and pledged to prevent future outbreaks of the anti-Israel, borderline anti-Semitic and anti-Semitic rhetoric identified by the ADL, AJC and Wiesenthal Center that appears on their site, blog and twitter from some of their staff, fellow members and bloggers, Media Matters continues to pay for and spout Jew-hatred. Spreading anti-Semitic and anti-Israel invective and inspiring others to join in their Jew-hatred is extremely dangerous and fundamentally incompatible with the values of USAia, the Democratic party and all civil discourse. Media Matters must end this disgrace or take ownership of it and be known as an anti-Semitic organization. Elected officials and other prominent democrats who associate with Media Matters may not be aware of the depth of the problem, but once they are alerted, they have a moral obligation to speak out publicly against this bigotry and cut ties with the group until it ends, unless of course they agree with Media Matters and neo-Nazis that it is a good idea to call elected officials and other pro-Israel USAians ‘Israel-Firsters.’
