blair’s “we need to get used to double standards” man defends bahrain

Robert Cooper, then UK PM Blair’s personal assistant for foreign affairs, wrote in his 1996 book “The Post-Modern State and World Order” (pp 42, 44-5): “We need to get used to the idea of double standards… Advice to post-modern states (i.e. us – RB): accept that intervention in the pre-modern (ie them – RB) is going to be a fact of life. Such interventions may not solve problems, but they may salve the conscience. And they are not necessarily the worse for that” – RB

Top EU official defends Bahrain crackdown
Andrew Rettman, EU Observer, Mar 23 2011

A senior advisor to EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton has defended Bahrain’s security forces after they opened fire on protesters with live ammunition last week. Speaking to MEPs in the foreign affairs committee in Brussels on Mar 22 after visiting Bahrain, Robert Cooper, Ashton’s top advisor on the western Balkans and the Middle East, said the island is normally “a rather pleasant, peaceful place.” He went on:

I’m not sure if the police have had to deal with these public order questions before. It’s not easy dealing with large demonstrations in which there may be violence. It’s a difficult task for policemen. It’s not something that we always get right in the best Western countries and accidents happen.

He noted that two policemen were also killed last week. Referring to opposition roadblocks on the Manama airport road, he added:

The situation had in fact, from the point of view of the management of Bahrain, which is a small island, become almost intolerable. One should understand the authorities were right to restore calm and order and that’s what they’ve done. But that is only right if it is followed by dialogue.

Bahrain security forces on Friday launched a crackdown on protesters in the capital’s Pearl Square reportedly killing four and injuring over 200. Amateur video footage showed heavily-armed balaclava-wearing men shooting at civilians. Shots were also fired into the crowd from convoys of jeeps and tanks were brought onto the streets in a level of violence described by the UN as “shocking”. Government forces later blocked off the main hospital, preventing doctors from treating casualties. The UN on Tuesday said that between 50 and 100 people have gone missing since the crackdown began, two of which have turned up dead. A doctor detained by security forces said he was severely beaten and threatened with rape. Cooper’s endorsement disturbed one MEP at the debate. German Green deputy Franziska Brantner said:

Accidents happen? I’m sorry, this is a funny picture as you describe it. What are you talking about? I find this very scary.

For his part, Ashton’s top diplomat in charge of the Middle East, Hugues Mingarelli, told MEPs the EU has no clout in the Gulf. He said:

To be realistic, the instruments at our disposal, the opportunities we have, are fairly restricted.

Turning to Yemen, Mingarelli predicted that Pres Saleh is likely to fall in a “few days”. He said:

I don’t see how the president can govern when part of the army, several tribal leaders and parts of his own government have distanced themselves from him. Things are getting out of control. Things are going to speed up in the next few days.

He added that the EU, or EU “eminent personalities” could go to mediate in Yemen if they are invited. German centre-right deputy Elmar Brok said the EU is applying double standards in its handling of Libya and of the Arabian Gulf killings. Speaking of President Saleh’s snipers aiming at people’s heads and of wounded children, he said:

I really can’t see the difference between what is happening in Libya and what is happening in Yemen.

Cooper, a former British diplomat and a writer, said in an essay in 2002:

The challenge to the post-modern world is to get used to the idea of double standards. Among ourselves, we operate on the basis of laws and open co-operative security. But when dealing with more old-fashioned kinds of states, we need to revert to the rougher methods of an earlier era: force, pre-emptive attack, deception.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: