i hope we can say: “all [x] are jews, qed” more often

Chosen indeed: all 7 letters run by NYT on Mideast article are by Jews
Philip Weiss, MondoWeiss, Aug 15 2016

elbaum Daniel Elbaum of the AJC, privileged letter writer

Last week the NYT ran a big article about the Middle East issue on campus that we criticized because of its theme that Jewish students are made fearful by criticism of Israel. The article thereby removed anti-Zionist Jews from the landscape and equated anti-Zionism with anti-semitism. Yesterday’s NYT ran seven letters responding to the article. Three made the point that Jews actually can be critical of Israel. One was by Rachel Sandalow-Ash of Open Hillel, another by Julia Mason Wedgle, saying that she was called an “anti-Semite” in Hillel at Tufts and found her real home as a Jew in the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter. The third was from Rebecca Vilkomerson of Jewish Voice for Peace:

Advocacy for Palestinian human rights is not at odds with Jewish identity. Many Jews, and especially students, support the use of nonviolent tactics such as BDS, and work alongside Palestinians and other people of conscience to bring about the political pressure needed to change Israel’s oppressive and discriminatory policies.

But here’s the rub. All seven letters were authored by… Jews. Vilkomerson made the point on twitter:

Here for the record are the other four members of the club:

  1. RICHARD M. JOEL
    New York
    The writer is president of Yeshiva University.
  2. SHIMON MERCER-WOOD
    The writer is the spokesman for the Consulate General of Israel in New York.
  3. ANDREW GOLDBLATT and AVIVA HERR-WELBER
    As student leaders in Tufts’s chapter of J Street U
  4. DANIEL ELBAUM
    Assistant Executive Director, American Jewish Committee, Chicago

Is this fair to non-Jews who may have an opinion? No. What about Arab Pindosis in Students for Justice in Palestine chapters, do they not have a voice? Nope. This selection obviously reflects a deep (structural!) bias at the NYT. IMHO that bias entails unconscious ethnocentric ideas about Jewish intelligence and our natural place in the social order. In a word, entitlement: In the media establishment a Jew counts as five thirds of all other persons.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s