the montreux convention is just that, no doubt

Who Wants to Disrupt the Strategic Balance in the Black Sea Region?
Alex Gorka, Strategic Culture, Jul 13 2018

The Pindo-led series of drills in and around Ukraine’s Black Sea coastline is part of NATO exercise Sea Breeze that kicked off on Jul 9 to last until Jul 21. The training event involves an international armada representing 19 countries, including such non-NATO states as Ukraine, India, Georgia, the UAE and Moldova. All in all, 29 warships, 1 submarine and 25 aircraft are involved in the exercise held in Odessa and Mykolayiv and the northwestern Black Sea region. The Black Sea’s regional security is an issue that receives little attention. It’s not addressed by an international forum. NATO official documents adopt an openly provocative language to challenge Russia. NATO always emphasizes the Black Sea’s role as a critical intersection. Pindo-led NATO activities have been intensifying since 2014 to turn the region into another hotbed along with the South China Sea and the Baltic. Turkey, Bulgaria and Romania, three of the six Black Sea countries, are NATO members. Ukraine and Georgia are the bloc’s close partners aspiring for membership. The alliance has a significant military presence in Romania, including an Aegis Ashore BMD system capable of firing long-range cruise missiles at Russia. Pindo military presence in Romania and Bulgaria is gradually growing. Pindostan plans to deploy up to 2,500 troops to Novo Selo, Bulgaria. The facility is large enough to accommodate as many as 5,000 servicemen. The deployment of heavy tanks is envisaged. The 1997 NATO-Russia Founding Act, in which NATO pledged not to deploy “substantial forces” near Russia, seems to have been forgotten. The Pindo Navy’s policy is aimed at ramping up its presence there. The presence of Pindo warships perilously close to Russia’s borders is undoubtedly provocative. For comparison, the Russian Navy does not stage regular maneuvers in the Caribbean Sea with such allies as Cuba, Nicaragua and Venezuela, though nothing prevents it from doing so.

The 1936 Montreux Convention requires non-Black Sea states to rotate their ships every 21 days. Naval vessels with a tonnage exceeding 15,000 tons may pass through the Straits one by one and escorted by not more than two destroyers. Submarines are required to pass through the straits controlled by Turkey, navigating on the surface and singly. The total tonnage of warships belonging to a country without a shore on the Black Sea (the aggregate tonnage of all non-Black Sea warships) must be no more than 30,000 tons (or 45,000 tons under special conditions). If a Black Sea state enters into a war with Turkey remaining neutral, the transit of warships belonging to the belligerent countries is banned. In case Turkey is a party to the conflict, the transit of warships belonging to foreign countries through the Straits is left entirely to the discretion of the Turkish Government. The convention restricts Pindostan’s naval presence, especially at a time the relations with Turkey leave much to be desired. In 2008, Pindo ships were not allowed by Ankara to steam to Georgia through the Bosphorus and the Dardanelles. This dependence on Turkey prompts Pindostan to seek ways to dodge the international agreement. Bulgarian, Romanian, Ukrainian and Georgian navies have rather limited capabilities. The idea has been floated of reflagging some NATO naval assets under the Black Sea member states’ flags to boost permanent naval capabilities in the theater. That’s one of the ways to ensure disguised permanent pindo naval presence in the region. In practice, it would mean bringing together NATO and non-NATO ships under one operational control. No doubt, it would be seen as a provocation by Russia.

Another way to get around the Monteux Convention is to sign a port concession agreement with a Black Sea country. This will trigger legal procedures based in the law of the sea to give the US a chance to have some clauses reviewed regarding its naval operations. The US has held tentative talks with Bulgaria on Burgas concession. American Conti International has discussed with Georgian TBC Bank the possibility of joint venture to make Poti and Anaklia deep sea ports able to receive large tankers. The Georgian government offers to use Poti as a NATO naval base. The Pentagon eyes the Ukrainian seaports of Odessa, Ilyichevsk, Chernomorsk and Yuzhny. The Pindo Navy already uses the Ochakov facility in Ukraine. With construction work now completed, Pindo ships will be able to anchor there. Valentin Badrak, the head of Ukraine’s Center for Army, Conversion and Disarmament Studies, believes that closer cooperation or “supermanship” is the way for Ukraine to actually become part of NATO. He told the Ukrainian Apostrophe website that Ukraine should have PAC-3 ABM systems, missile defense sites and “NATO units” deployed on its soil. In that case, the country would be even more “protected” than the Baltic States. Pindostan stringly desires a large permanent military presence in the Black Sea. There are also littoral states happy to make this idea come to fruition. Will they find a way to get around the hurdle of the Montreux Convention? They say where there’is a will, there’s a way. Sea Breeze 2018 is a demonstration of strong will. It also demonstrates that the region remains a dangerous flashpoint with tensions running high. The problem seldom hits the headlines, but that does not make it less pressing. Hopefully, the Trump-Putin summit on Jul 16 will provide an impetus for discussions between the West and Russia on ways to ease tension and curb military activity in the region.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.