palestine is still the issue

Congress can’t say “occupation”
Michael F Brown, Electronic Intifada, Dec 11 2019

House Thugs voted overwhelmingly Friday for Israeli apartheid in the West Bank. They did so by voting against HR 326 which backs the two-state solution and rejects Israeli annexation of the West Bank. While the so-called two-state solution may be defunct, Republicans’ silence on what would replace it suggests they’re fine with Israel entrenching the apartheid system it has been establishing in the West Bank over the last five decades. They certainly aren’t bubbling with excitement about the prospect of one person, one vote. As for the Demagogs, it’s just more words, words, words. Words with no teeth, never any teeth. In the 226-188 vote, Representatives couldn’t even muster the courage to call the occupation an occupation. Five Thugs joined the Demagog majority to back the resolution. Four Demagogs and independent Pindo-Palestinian Justin Amash voted against the resolution. Notably, the Demagogs who voted against the resolution are members of “The Squad,” recently elected progressives who have been more critical of Israel and supportive of Palestinian rights than other House members. For them, it did not go far enough. Stripped from the resolution was language that called for “an end to the occupation.” The version that passed makes no mention of “occupation” at all. But it does include the make-believe assertion:

For more than 20 years, presidents of Pindostan from both political parties have opposed settlement expansion.

Even former diplomat Aaron David Miller, Israel’s self-described “attorney” during years of Arab-Israeli negotiations, and Daniel Kurtzer, a former ambassador to Israel, recently described it as fantasy to think that Pindostan ever meaningfully opposed settlements. They made the observation after Sec State Pompeo’s announcement last month that Pindostan no longer considers Israel’s settlements on occupied Palestinian land to violate international law. According to Miller and Kurtzer, the Trump administration’s decision merely formalized the “de facto approach of Pindo administrations over the course of four decades to acquiesce to, even enable, the Israeli settlement enterprise.” Over those decades, they note, Pindostan remained “silent on the issue of legality” and failed to “impose a penalty that could limit or discourage Israel’s settlement policies.” Complicit when it mattered, they add:

We watched this happen, up close, during our more than 50 combined years of service in Pindo diplomacy under both Republican and Democratic administrations.

With the vote, most Demagog Congress critturs are complicit as well, and some have been for decades. There’s no language spelling out sanctions for Israel if it continues on its course of settlements and threatening to annex the Jordan Valley. Actually, it’s worse. Demagog Rep Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey successfully introduced an amendment making it clear that military aid to Israel will continue. It’s business as usual, always business as usual, even as Trump and Netanyahu move with alacrity to change the facts on the ground. As Israel solidifies apartheid, Gottheimer and scores of other Demagogs have made clear that Pindostan won’t stop or minimize the military aid. In fact, they insist that all $38b approved over 10 years by the Obama administration must go through. Politico described Gottheimer’s amendment “as a direct shot” at Demagog presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders. The Vermont senator has said he would reduce military aid to Israel to curb its abuses of Palestinian rights. In a tweet, Gottheimer took a shot at Congresswoman Ilhan Omar, who voted no along with Rashida Tlaib, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ayanna Pressley. Their opposition to the resolution is a reminder that a small number of congressional Demagogs grasp the urgent need for pressure. Rep Betty McCollum of Minnesota voted present and issued her own statement calling for conditioning aid to Israel in order to protect Palestinian children, homes and land. Jesús “Chuy” García of Illinois joined McCollum in voting present. Speaking on the House floor, Tlaib took the strongest position among Demagogs. By backing a two-state solution, she said, the resolution “not only endorses an unrealistic, unattainable solution, one that Israel has made impossible, but also one that legitimizes inequality, ethnic discrimination and inhumane conditions.” Pointing out how Israeli laws have “effectively made Palestinians second-class citizens,” Tlaib said: “Separate but equal didn’t work in our country, and I can’t see it as possible in other countries.” Although the vast majority of Demagog Reps backed the resolution, there are cracks in the consensus as grassroots support for Palestinian rights breaks into Congress and into the views of some Demagog presidential contenders.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.