scott ritter on erdogan’s chances

Turkey faces strategic defeat in Idlib after failing to live up to its commitments on Syria
Scott Ritter,, Feb 19 2020

Turkish commandos with APCs in Reyhanli, Feb 13 2020.
Photo: Cem Genco/Anadolu

When Turkey threw its weight behind the anti-Assad rebellion in 2011, it did so believing that it would be able to dictate the outcome on the ground by controlling the main organized resistance forces, the Free Syrian Army (FSA), formed from the ranks of defectors from the Syria Arab Army (SAA) and various bands of Islamist fighters affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood (MB). But the rebellion took on a life of its own and in 2012 Abu Mohammad al-Jolani, a Syrian Islamist fighting for AQI, returned to Syria to form a new resistance organization loyal to AQ, which became known as Jabhat al-Nusra. Over time, it emerged as the most effective anti-regime combat organization, surpassing the Turkish-controlled FSA for relevance on the battlefield. Nusra’s AQ affiliation, impaired its ability to receive outside funding, arms and equipment, and starting in 2015 it underwent a series of rebranding efforts, before assuming its current name, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) in early 2017. But the rebranding efforts could not alter the fact that HTS remained a designated terrorist group in the eyes of much of the world, including Turkey.

Today, Jolani’s HTS comprises the bulk of the 30,000 or so anti-regime fighters operating in Idlib province, the last bastion of rebel-controlled territory in Syria. The SAA, backed by pro-Iranian militias and Russian Aerospace Forces (RAF), has been attacking both FSA and HTS positions in Idlib since 2015 to restore Syrian government authority over the area. In Sep 2018, to spare the civilian population in Idlib from the depravations of war, a ceasefire was agreed to by the leaders of Russia, Turkey and Iran during a summit convened in Sochi. Under the terms of the Sochi Agreement, Russia and Syria would forego offensive military operations in Idlib in exchange for Turkey enforcing so-called disengagement zones (DEZs), where anti-regime forces would surrender their heavy weapons and fighters from designated terrorist organizations such as HTS would be disarmed and evacuated. To support this effort, Turkey established a series of heavily-armed observation posts throughout the DEZs. However, instead of disarming the FSA and evicting HTS, Turkey used the outposts as a deterrence for any renewed offensive action by the SAA & RAF. In short, Turkey failed to live up to virtually the totality of its commitments under Sochi.

By the summer of 2019, both Russia and Syria decided that the ceasefire was no longer in effect, and renewed their offensive, targeting HTS forces dug in in and around the designated DEZs. This offensive has succeeded in destroying or displacing tens of thousands of HTS fighters, resulting in numerous strategic towns being recaptured by the SAA, along with vast swaths of territory. The Turkish forces in the observation posts were powerless to stop the offensive, and by Feb 2020, ten out of the twelve observation posts had been surrounded by the SAA. The seeming impotence of the Turkish military in the face of the combined SAA & RAF attack both enraged and embarrassed Erdogan, who dispatched some 5,000 soldiers accompanied by hundreds of pieces of military equipment, including tanks, armored fighting vehicles and artillery pieces into Idlib. Some of these forces were taken under fire by the SAA, with at least 13 Turkish soldiers being killed. Turkey claims to have responded in kind, killing scores of Syrian soldiers. The loss of life only angered Erdogan further, prompting him to threaten both the SAA and RAF operating in Idlib with destruction if they did not withdraw back to the positions occupied at the time of the Sochi agreement.

The response of the SAA & RAF was to continue the attack, resulting in even more towns and territory being returned to Syrian government control. By failing to comply with its obligations under the Sochi agreement to disarm and disband HTS units operating inside Idlib province, Turkey opened the door for the current ongoing offensive action by forces belonging to Syria and Russia. By dispatching thousands of Turkish troops into Idlib, Erdogan was hoping neither Russia nor Syria would seek to escalate the fighting in Idlib to include force-on-force engagements with a NATO member. When a Russian military delegation dispatched to the Turkish capital Ankara early last week was not able to convince their Turkish counterparts to back down, Erdogan doubled down by deploying even more troops and equipment into Idlib, and threatening to forcefully expel the SAA by month’s end if they did not cease their attacks. The SAA responded by surrounding even more Turkish military outposts, recapturing all of Aleppo from HTS and FSA forces, and driving deeper into HTS-held territory. Erdogan’s bluff had been effectively called.

The Turks now find themselves in an impossible situation. In a desperate bid to isolate itself from HTS, the Turks ordered all FSA forces that had been dispatched to reinforce HTS-controlled territory to return to Turkish-controlled territory, effectively isolating HTS forces on the battlefield, where they have subsequently either been destroyed or forced to retreat deeper into what remains of their Idlib bastion. For the Turkish troops still deployed inside Idlib, their situation has become increasingly perilous. Their numbers and dispositions preclude any chance of a meaningful defense of Idlib, even if the decision was made to engage the RAF & SAA. The best the Turks can hope for at this juncture is a new ceasefire that allows their military forces in Idlib to be withdrawn safely with their honor intact. In any event, by aligning its interests with those of Jolani and HTS, in violation of the 2018 Sochi Agreement, Turkey has made its position in Idlib unsustainable both militarily and politically. Under the 2018 Sochi agreement, Turkey was supposed to disarm and disassociate itself from HTS. Its failure to do so has sown the seeds of Turkey’s inevitable defeat in Syria.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.