bogus jewish philanthropy figures

The AP story I made the comment to Haaretz about, which can be found below, says:

Experts estimate that about 5% of all money donated by American Jews — and 20% donated particularly to Jewish causes — goes to Israel …

thus implying that only a quarter of American Jewish charity giving is donated specifically to Jewish causes. However, when you look at the report from which they are quoting and check the definitions, you find that:

Some grants to secular institutions were designated for Jewish purposes, for example, Jewish studies programs at universities. These are classified, nevertheless, as secular. Similarly, grants can be made to Jewish organizations to serve the general public, and these are classified as Jewish, because the grant recipient is a Jewish institution. All giving to Israel, regardless of purpose, is considered Jewish …
http://www.jewishresearch.org/PDFs/Jewish.Foundations.pdf (2007)

The artificially low figure of only 25% of all Jewish-American charity being donated to specifically ‘Jewish’ causes is obtained by not counting donations to non-religiously Jewish causes, such as, for example, Jewish studies programs at (secular) universities. Suppose that we added all the Jewish causes that are not religiously Jewish in the USA, we might reach 50%. Secular Jewish welfare organisations abound overwhelmingly, and none of them are included, from Jewish studies departments at (secular) universities, outwards.

2 Comments

  1. Posted December 18, 2008 at 11:25 pm | Permalink

    That’s very true, they are always using that. We should do a better job with our sermon on how Jewishness is a matter of functionally national identity rather than any sort of metaphysical explanation of nature, which is what most Western religions can be counted as.

  2. Posted December 29, 2008 at 11:10 pm | Permalink

    We think it was Paul Findley who was tracing Jewish money in American politics, such as is marshalled to sink any candidate insufficiently loyal to haFatherland by flooding their opponent with cash. The funds are well-organized and named suspiciously innocuously, “Librarians of New Jersey” and so forth, and the only thing LoNJ ever gave money to was the JNF and a wildly-pro-israel candidate outside of New Jersey, and the guy in charge happens to be connected to ten other funds with similarly innocent names.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.